Ong Ai Ling is Head of AIOI (Artificial Intelligence of Investments) at Lion Global Investors. She started her investment career in London and has 18 years of experience managing Asia-Pacific and global equity investments. She debunks the myths surrounding Artificial Intelligence in Investing in our True or False series.
ChatGPT can tell me what stocks to buy. I can trust the financial advice from an AI.
Ong Ai Ling: False. You should not be relying on a generic AI (Artificial Intelligence) model like ChatGPT for financial advice. AI is like tools in a toolbox. You need to know which tools to use for what purposes, and how they need to be customised for their specific purpose. So ChatGPT is a very advanced Large Language Model. It was built to learn and replicate human language, specifically for communication purposes. It may appear very intelligent, but that is actually just because it is very knowledgeable. In the same way that if you have a lawyer friend who might be very knowledgeable about the law and is a smart person. But, if the lawyer has not been trained in finance, would you really want to be taking financial advice from a lawyer?
In fact, here at Lion Global Investors, we also have a transformer-based model, and this transformer architecture is very similar to the transformer architecture that ChatGPT uses. But specifically, we have trained it for financial data. We have tuned the parameters for financial purposes. This is just one of the many models that we have in our toolkit, and we have used multiple models in order to achieve the best financial outcomes.
The more complex a model, the better it will be at predicting financial returns.
Ong Ai Ling: Interestingly, false. In the artificial intelligence and machine learning world, we generally consider the complexity of a model based on its computational requirements. In other words, a number of iterative calculations the machine needs to make, and that is what determines its computational complexity. The markets will often think that the more complex the model, the better it must be. But very often we find that a well-tuned, properly customised, simpler model using properly cleaned inputs could be more robust and perform better than a complex black box model. Ong Ai Ling: Furthermore, the inputs themselves are an art and a science. Data cleaning, feature engineering. These are just some terms you will hear data scientists talk about. What it refers to is the choice of inputs that we use, how you prepare them, how you normalise the inputs. All these decisions effectively require some form of domain knowledge. What we mean by domain knowledge is the experience and knowledge that you pick up in the field of finance over time. You often hear the phrase "garbage in, garbage out." This is particularly true in finance because the data that we work with and deal with is inherently very noisy, subjective and changes all the time.
At Lion Global Investors, we adopt a “human-in-the-loop” approach. We believe that by constantly checking on the accuracy of our inputs and the consistency of our models, we will be able produce a better outcome.
AI machines can build new AI machines themselves. They do not need humans anymore!
Ong Ai Ling: True and false both, actually. From a technical perspective, yes, it is possible you can have one Siri speaking to another Siri. In the same way, you can tell ChatGPT to program another algorithm to do X, Y and Z. Technically it works, but what we found is that it tends to lead to an eventual model collapse.
There was a piece of research done in 2023, and it is called "The Curse of Recursion". This is an experiment where they used a self-feeding process where one AI is fed with the outputs from another AI. Eventually, both AI started producing rubbish. Both models just collapsed. This highlights the importance of having a “human-in-the-loop” approach or what in AI terms you call “reinforcement learning with human feedback”. At Lion Global Investors, we adopt a “human-in-the-loop” approach. We believe that having human checks and balances whereby we constantly check on the accuracy of our inputs and if the consistency of our models produces a better outcome.
Ask ChatGPT the same question 10 times and it will give you 10 different answers.
Ong Ai Ling: True. ChatGPT and other Large Language Models work on what we call a "probabilistic basis." In other words, the model inherently introduces an element of randomness deliberately. The outputs are not deterministic, ie. they are not repeatable. So, when you ask the same question once, it will give you a different answer each time you ask it.
However, in finance we generally prefer deterministic models such that when I start with the same inputs and I keep every other parameter the same, it should give me the same output. Even when we want to introduce some randomness into the model, we will do so in a very controlled fashion. We might look at sampling in controlled intervals, and even then, we have to think about how we average out the outcomes and how we think about the probability distribution or the confidence intervals that the outcome represents.
Share this article
Related Insights
Disclaimer
This advertisement or publication has not been reviewed by the Monetary Authority of Singapore. It is for information only, and is not a recommendation, offer or solicitation for the purchase or sale of any capital markets products or investments and does not have regard to your specific investment objectives, financial situation, tax position or needs. Investments in the products mentioned herein are not obligations of, deposits in, guaranteed or insured by LGI or any of its affiliates and are subject to investment risks including the possible loss of the principal amount invested. You may wish to seek advice from a financial adviser before making a commitment to undertake any investment. In the event that you choose not to seek advice from a financial adviser, you should consider carefully whether the investment is suitable for you.
The information presented herein is for illustrative purposes only and should not be considered reflective of any particular security, strategy, or investment product. It represents a general assessment of the markets at a specific time and is not a guarantee of future performance results or market movement. Any opinions, projections or forward-looking statements expressed herein or information presented (which includes estimates, graphs, charts, formulae or devices) is subject to change or correction at any time without notice and is not to be relied on as advice. You are advised to conduct your own independent assessment and investigation of the relevance, accuracy, adequacy and reliability of any information contained herein and seek professional advice on them. No warranty is given and no liability is accepted for any loss arising directly or indirectly as a result of you acting on such information.
References to specific corporations/companies and/or their trademarks are not intended as recommendations to purchase or sell investments in such corporations/companies nor do they directly or indirectly express or imply any sponsorship, affiliation, certification, association, approval, connection or endorsement between any of these corporations/companies and LGI or the products and services of LGI. It should not be assumed that investment in the securities mentioned was or will be profitable.
This publication is not intended for use by any person other than the intended recipient and may not be reproduced, distributed or published without prior written consent of LGI. This publication may not be distributed in any jurisdiction or to any person where such distribution is prohibited (including Canada, Japan, the United States of America) or to US persons (as such term is defined in Regulation S under the US Securities Act of 1933).
©Lion Global Investors® Limited (UEN/ Registration No. 198601745D) is a Singapore incorporated company, and is not related to any asset or fund management entity that is domiciled in Europe or the United States.